"So whether you eat or drink or whatever you do, do it all for the glory of God." 1 COR 10:31

RESTAURANTS

Right at the Essenhaus — Middlebury 

• Das Dutchman Essenhaus — 240 US-20, Middlebury ⭐ 4.6 
  •  Indiana's largest and friendliest family-style restaurant, serving warm hospitality and authentic Amish recipes passed down for generations. There are multiple ways to dine:
  • Buffet, family-style, and menu dining are all available, featuring generations-old authentic Amish-style recipes. 
  • They're also famous for over 30 varieties of fresh-baked pies. 
  • The all-you-can-eat buffet is $19.99/person. 
  • The Bakery on site offers breads, rolls, cookies, and 30 varieties of pie fresh from the oven, plus homemade favorites like apple butter and their own noodles. 
  • Hours: 
    • Thu–Sat 6:30am–8pm
      

Middlebury

• The Hilltop Restaurant — 300 Wayne St, Middlebury ⭐ 4.4 
  • A beloved small-town diner serving breakfast all day, generous portions of comfort food, and daily specials at very reasonable prices. 
  • Hours
    • Thu–Sat 6am–8pm
      
• West on Warren Gallery + Grill — 200 W Warren St, Middlebury ⭐ 4.6 
  • A charming American grill with a patio.
  • Creative menu, full bar.
  • Hours:
    • Thu–Fri 11am–8pm
    • Sat until 9pm
      
• 14th Street Barbeque — 335 N Main St, Middlebury ⭐ 4.7 
  • Right in downtown Middlebury, inside the Creamery on Main. Smoked meats made on-site — brisket, pulled pork, ribs, burnt ends. 
  • Steps from Dips on the Vine and the Pumpkinvine Trail. 
  • Open daily 11am–7pm
    
• Wedgewood Brewing Company — 129 Orpha Dr, Middlebury ⭐ 4.7 
  • Smash burgers, burnt end sandwiches, craft beer, and a great atmosphere. 
  • Open Thu–Sat
    

Goshen

• Biebs & Ash — 133 S Main St, Goshen ⭐ 4.7 
  • Downtown Goshen's smash burger destination.
  • Casual, fun, great for a group. 
  • Open Thu–Sat
    
• Venturi — 123 E Lincoln Ave, Goshen ⭐ 4.6 
  • Neapolitan pizza with imported Italian ingredients, handmade pastas, and a full bar. The fig pizza and tiramisu get raves. 
  • Open Thu–Sun for lunch and dinner
    
• The Table at 108 — 108 N Main St, Goshen ⭐ 4.4 
  • Fresh, authentic Italian in a polished downtown setting. The gnocchi and pappardelle are standouts. 
  • Dinner only, Thu–Sat 4:30–9pm
    
• Nova's — 109 E Lincoln Ave, Goshen ⭐ 4.9 
  • A newer gem in downtown Goshen with a creative menu, beautiful atmosphere, and owners on-site every night. 
  • Open Thu–Sat 4–9pm
    
• The Fold — 219 S Main St, Goshen ⭐ 4.6 
  • Pizza by the slice or whole pie, craft beer, full bar. Great for a casual group night out. 
  • Note: kids can get takeout but the dining room is 21+ due to bar setup. 
  • Open Thu–Sun
    
• El Patrón Mexican Restaurant — 231 Chicago Ave, Goshen ⭐ 4.3 
  • Festive atmosphere with hand-painted murals, authentic Mexican food, and strong margaritas. 
  • Open Daily

• Goshen Brewing Company — 315 W Washington St, Goshen ⭐ 4.6
  • Farm-to-table seasonal menu, craft beer, outdoor patio on the Millrace River.  
  • Open Thu–Sun
    

Shipshewana

• Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery — 195 N Van Buren St, Shipshewana ⭐ 4.5 
  • Another major Amish-style restaurant in the area.
  • Family-style and buffet with fried chicken, chicken and noodles, mashed potatoes, and outstanding pies. 
  • Also has a gift shop, and bakery.
  • Open Thy–Sat 10:30am–7/8pm
    
• The Black Sheep From Scratch Kitchen — 125½ Harrison St, Shipshewana ⭐ 5.0 
  • A small, family-run gem tucked off the main street. Everything scratch-made — great Reubens, burgers, soups. 
  • Notably the only restaurant in Shipshewana with a full liquor license. 
  • Open Fri–Sun only 11am–7/8pm.
    
• Millie's Market Cafe — 225 N Harrison St, Shipshewana ⭐ 4.5 
  • On the third floor of Davis Mercantile, with a rooftop patio. 
  • Simple, affordable Amish comfort food — chicken and noodles, sandwiches, fresh pies, hand-scooped ice cream. 
  • Perfect for a lunch stop while shopping. 
  • Open Thu–Sat 11am–3pm
    

COFFEE

• The Electric Brew — 118 E Washington St, Goshen ⭐ 4.6 
  • Goshen's beloved original coffee shop, open since 1996. A true community hub in the heart of downtown. 
  • Open daily
    
• Chocolatte — 1100 Chicago Ave #19, Goshen ⭐ 4.8 
  • Inside the historic Old Bag Factory. Artisan chocolates, exceptional coffee, and a stunning atmosphere. 
  • Open Thu–Fri 9am–5pm, and Sat until 8pm.
    
• Canelé Café — 212 W Washington St, Goshen ⭐ 4.9 
  • A French-inspired bakery-café in an old farmers market building. 
  • Hours
    • Thu–Fri 9am–4pm
    • Sat 9am–1pm
      
• Cabin Coffee Co. — 707 Lincolnway E, Goshen ⭐ 4.7 
  • Fun cabin-themed shop with drive-through, full breakfast menu, and cozy vibes. 
  • Hours:
    • Thu–Fri 6am–1pm
    • Sat 7am–1pm
      
• Coffee Depot — 1021 E Kercher Rd, Goshen ⭐ 4.7 
  • Full breakfast and lunch café with gluten-free options and great lattes. 
  • Hours:
    • Thu–Fri 6am–3pm
    • Sat 7am–2pm
      
• Refinery Coffee Company — 1525 W Wilden Ave, Goshen ⭐ 4.9 
  • A specialty roaster where everything is locally roasted fresh. More of a drip-coffee and beans experience, but a gem. 
  • Hours: 
    • Thu–Fri 9am–5pm
    • Sat 9am–2pm